95 POINTS
Jeni Port - Winepilot
The block was planted in 1969 and so we are looking at 56 -year-old vines officially classified as ‘old vine.’ There is an impressive flavour concentration associated with old vines off a good patch of land, and it’s a feature of this wine. So, too, is a high tannin presence. Kidman Block is always associated with a high potential for further ageing upon release, the ’23 is no different. Red earth, sage, black pepper, anise gather around blackberry fruit with a whisper of black olive savouriness emerging. It’s early days but you have to appreciate the aromatic lift, the fineness of expression and the promise that is to come. Everything is in place. It’s now a question of patience. For me, I love the blackberry, blueberry freshness now, the spices and the long finish. It speaks of the region and its quiet achiever of a grape. It’s a strong temptation to open now. . . very strong.
94 POINTS
Ken Gargett - Winepilot
Only 120 dozen of this thoroughly enjoyable Shiraz produced. Maturation was in French oak hogsheads for a period of sixteen months, 20% of them new. Deep maroon with a magenta rim, there is good oak integration evident here although one suspects that it is still in process. On the nose, we have notes of leather, aniseed, herbs, soy, beef stock and black fruits. A wine of focus, concentration and balance, it will be better in a year or two and then drink beautifully for the next decade. A long finish which offers bright acidity and sleek tannins.
93 POINTS
Tom Kline - Winepilot
The Kidman Block Shiraz comes from 50+ year old vines in Tim Kidman’s vineyard in the northern end of the terra rossa cigar. This spent 16 months in French oak hogsheads with 20% of the final blend. White pepper spice, dark cherry, blood plum and cured meat aromas sit cool and restrained in the glass before an unfurling of earth, blackberry, peppercorn and menthol. Some dusty cedar-like notes beneath. It’s restrained and poised aromatically, with an attractive mix of savouriness and dark fruit. The palate is at once lifted and mouth filling, with dark cherry, plum and blackberry at the fore, followed by cedar, pepperberry and earth before fine-grained tannins and cherry-laced acidity frame it up through a long finish. The cool 2023 vintage shows in this wine, which is more about seductive delicacy and restraint than showy power and drive.
93 POINTS
Campbell Mattinson - The Wine Front
Parker seems to have dropped the “Coonawarra” from its name. This shiraz is grown on a block planted in 1969. Sixteen months in all-French oak, 20% new. It’s not dense but it’s convincing. Blood plum, red cherry, orange rind and dry, earthen spice notes push confidently throughout, rakes of tannin marking out the finish. You have to admire the structure of this wine, the (exquisite) balance of fruit and oak, the authority of the finish. There’s nothing flamboyant about this wine but it’s perfectly formed, and will cellar very well as a result.
Erin Larkin - Robert Parker Wine Advocate
The 2023 Kidman Block Shiraz is light, leafy and a little minty, with bramble, cedar and freshly grated nutmeg. The fruit doesn't have a lot of carry through the finish, and this may be down to the challenging growing season that was experienced in this part of the world. If so, this is a tremendous effort in trying conditions.