97 POINTS
Tony Love - Winepilot
A best fruit parcel, best barrel selection Shiraz from a long and slow ripening McLaren Vale season which has resulted in a wine that brings the true meaning of “Reserve” into a focus that is rarely genuinely experienced. An initial balanced inter-weave of oak and fruit is a guarantee of the finesse that follows, built upon 24 months maturation in 10-15% new French hogshead barrels, carrying equal influence with further aromas of mint chocolate biscuit and stylish mulberry/blue berry/ red plum flavours, a dash of white pepper and a sticky tannin finish. There’s a fair deal of concentration within, which brings that extra meaning of having it all in “Reserve”. For now it is upright and sophisticated in its expression, entirely convincing, and a genuine keeper.
97 POINTS
Sam Kim - Wine Orbit
Immensely complex and captivating, the bouquet shows dark fruit richness, baking spice, vanillin oak, cracked pepper, and dark cocoa aromas. The powerfully expressed palate exhibits outstanding concentration and expansive mouthfeel, combined with finely infused tannins, finishing impressively long and alluring.
97 POINTS
Jeni Port - Winepilot
A McLaren Vale Shiraz at the top of its game where power meets a seamless, flavour-rich, complex wine. There is a generosity of flavour, the kind it takes two seconds to warm to, in ripe black cherry, plum and blueberry fruits against a background filled with spices, vanilla and lifted aromatics and dusty cocoa. Delivered on a smooth-running palate, it is well measured within an almost steeliness of tannin structure. It is built to last. Love the lick of spice to close, a rising note that seals a beautiful wine.
96 POINTS
Ken Gargett - Winepilot
This is the Estate’s flagship wine, McLaren Vale Shiraz, as it should be. Maturation is for two years in French oak hogsheads, up to 15% of them new. A powerful and dense Shiraz, the colour here is an opaque maroon with a deep garnet rim. The nose exhibits notes of redcurrants, chocolate, spices, coffee grinds, cassis, black fruits and mocha. There is well handled oak which is evident, though it remains in the background. The wine is seriously long and the texture supple and seductive. Early complexity is evident, and the wine finishes with silky tannins. A fifteen year proposition, longer if needed.
95 POINTS
Shanteh Wale - Winepilot
The wine spends 24 months resting in seasoned French oak hogsheads of which 10-15% was new oak. This opens with a well of dark fruit, blackberries, soft licorice and vanilla pod. There is a sense of sweet oak but well integrated through fruit and granitic soils. Some plush tannins and acidity that steers the wine into the next sip, quite moreish, in fact. There is a glossy element that ensures you know you are drinking the top tier of the offering but with poise and an echoing elegance of fruit as the focus. A wine that stands tall, without imposing itself. This calls for slow cooked veal and an excellent beef jus. Drink now or cellar for another decade.
95 POINTS
Marcus Ellis - Halliday Wine Companion
There’s a child-friendly hedge maze at Maxwell, if the Cretan myth is less so. This comes off 1972-planted estate vines, with maturation in French oak for between 20 and 24 months, with 10–15% new oak. The top of the Maxwell shiraz pile in terms of price and more classic in modelling, befitting the hefty wax-sealed bottle and ‘reserve’ tag. As with all wines here, this feels like it has had a subtle makeover. Yet still, a storm of dark fruits, black plums and berries, bitter chocolate and anise, buffed new leather, vanilla, clove and allspice. It’s impactful, though not too imposing, a mineral thread and fine line of acidity yielding some verve. Older-style echoes, but not old-fashioned.
95 POINTS
Lisa Cardelli - Winepilot
The opening is quite herbal, with cooking herbs, tomato leaf, freshly brewed oolong tea, followed by bilberries, miso, blue plums and fresh shiitake mushrooms. The palate is thick, with mouth-coating tannins that are stretchy and filling at the same time. A long, persistent finish, with plenty of mouth-watering acidity keeping the generous nature of the wine in perfect balance. A compelling wine with years ahead of it.