97 POINTS
Sam Kim - Wine Orbit
Immensely complex and gratifying, the wine shows perfumed aromas of dark cherry, warm spice and earthy mushroom on the nose with nuances of game, vanilla and cedar. It’s impressively concentrated and persistent on the palate, displaying sumptuous mouthfeel and plush texture, while remaining classically structured and refined.
A very impressive pinot for the complexity and richness it offers on the nose with earthy, savory elements, intertwined with rich, dark and red cherries, as well as dried flowers and woody spices. The palate has a very intense and plush feel with plenty of dark cherries and plums, wrapped in smooth and polished tannin. Drink over the next decade or more.
94 POINTS
Gary Walsh - The Wine Front
Power and intensity so often the theme with Pegasus Bay Pinot. Distinctive wines from this estate. Dark cherry, plum, roast meat with thyme, spice, dark chocolate and peel, along with toasty oak. Firm, packed with intense flavour, chocolate and chicory, layers of dusty tannin, spice and a savoury finish of prodigious length, dry tannin pushing through. Still pretty elemental as at now, with more to unfurl.
93 POINTS
Joe Czerwinski - Robert Parker Wine Advocate
Peg Bay's 2016 Prima Donna Pinot Noir is atypically taut and crisp, with fresh raspberries joining sandalwood on the nose. It's medium to full-bodied, enlivened by vibrant acidity and framed by just-barely-ripe tannins of sturdy silk, finishing long and intense, hinting at cranberries and mocha.
Strong ruby with purple reflections and a delicate water edge. Inviting, attractive floral bouquet, pickled cherry and fresh orange zest. Juicy, round and harmonious with well-integrated tannins and sweet red berry fruit on the finish.
Tim Jackson MW - JancisRobinson.com
From good vintages only, typically from particular, original, oldest-vine plantings. 12 different clones. 33% whole bunches and 70% destemmed, of which around half are whole berries. Fermented and held for two weeks on skins. Natural MLF then blended. New and old barriques for 18–22 months to soften tannins. Not to be released for another 18 months as reserve wines are held for two years rather than one.Pale-mid purple. Rich, ripe blackberry with cordite oak spice, some dried herb and a little violet lift. Precise, violet floral and blackberry fruit. Some chew to the tannins, but they are coming around. Medium-long to long. Powerful style, with a touch of heat but juicy, brisk acidity too. Score: 16/20