99 POINTS
James Halliday - Halliday Wine Companion
From vines planted in '71. Hand-picked, destemmed, fermented separately on skins for 18 days, matured for 15 months in high quality French barrels. The best shiraz and cabernet are selected to showcase this long-time Australian blend. If there's a better one, I haven't seen it. This is a beautiful wine, red and black fruits holding hands as they so brilliantly throw off the shackles of the hot vintage.
Wow, this is a phenomenal expression of this majestic Clarendon vineyard and is aptly named as the pinnacle of the range. The intersection of cabernet sauvignon and shiraz is so seamless, a selection of the best (and oldest) parcels form this blend. The fact they are both grown in the same contoured vineyard cements a deep bond in this wine. Dark cherries, blackberries, mulberries and blackcurrants with a gently leafy edge. The oak is perfectly integrated. Power and precision on the palate. So well defined and brightly flavored with raspberries, red plums, blackberries and a deeper, black-cherry and dark-plum build into the finish. Just superb. Drink over the next 15+ years.
96 POINTS
Campbell Mattinson - The Wine Front
This isn’t released until July 2020 but if Australian cabernet shiraz blends are to your liking then this release is worth jumping on as soon as you can. It’s a seriously good wine. Its volume and silken mouthfeel announce themselves from the first sip but then the long chains of tannin, tobacco and dust and floral-like highlights, and compelling length serve to seal a quite wonderful deal. This is hearty, full-bodied Australian red wine in all its glory. It’s built on redcurrant, plum, blackcurrant and cloves and the mouthfeel/length combination here is really quite something.
This stunning wine offers a deep and generous mix of wild blackberry, blueberry and cassis flavors at the core that are juicy and fresh, with notes of dark chocolate and cumin and a touch of smoked paprika. Tannins are thick and velvety, adding a wonderful density and toothsome quality. Shows plenty of harmony on the long, expressive finish.
95 POINTS
Joe Czerwinski - Robert Parker Wine Advocate
Hickinbotham's flagship 2018 The Peake Cabernet Shiraz checks in as a blend of 55% Cabernet Sauvignon and 45% Shiraz. Aged in 50% to 60% new French oak, the Shiraz component is drawn from the "drippings"—not the free-run that comes off the skins immediately, but not pressings, either. The two varieties complement each other, with the Shiraz adding richness of texture—a certain lushness and velvety feel that the pure-Cabernet Trueman is missing. Cassis and raspberry notes combine with hints of cedar and vanilla, mint and dried spices. Medium to full-bodied, this is velvety, rich, long and complete, just a joy to drink.
95 POINTS
Erin Larkin - Robert Parker Wine Advocate
The 2018 The Peake Cabernet Shiraz is 55% Cabernet Sauvignon and the balance Shiraz, and the wine has a restraint and evenness about it that is most intriguing. 2018 was a warm year in South Australia, but I have found the red wines to have incredible energy and freshness despite that. In the mouth, the wine is cedar and sweet, textural and savory, long and persistent. There are attractive notes of bay leaf and cedar, tobacco and tapenade. This is an excellent wine. 14% alcohol, sealed under screw cap.
95 POINTS
Christina Pickard - Wine Enthusiast
The longer Napa winemaker Chris Carpenter spends in McLaren Vale, the more in tune he seems to be with the country's palate and the region's unique terroirs. This is a precise and highly age worthy example of Oz's most famed red blend. Fleshy plum and blueberry fruit mingles with mint and other dried herbs, chocolate, bay leaf and peppery spice. The barrel influence is there too, but it's better integrated than in the past. At the moment the palate is a beast, with oodles of fruit and spice and muscular, chalky tannins, but there's chisel, finesse and a lengthy finish—all the trimmings of a harmonious wine set for the long haul. Drink until 2040.